Skip to main content

When is an ad more than an ad?

11/20/2013 01:58PM, Published by ACL, Categories: Schools



Everyone agrees that advertising is part of life. Students, in particular, are bombarded with commercial messages every day. 

Last year, the Unionville-Chadds Ford School District decided to jump in and accept advertising as a way to boost district revenues and fund major projects. Everyone on the school board and in the administration thought this was a good idea. But the policy has proven to be a minefield. On Monday night, the school board wrestled for the third time with what kinds of advertising can be allowed.

When it comes to naming a stadium or putting a huge ad on a school scoreboard, there needs to be careful, prolonged discussion. But selling a 2-by-2 ad inside a playbill, for instance, seems to be a fairly non-controversial thing. 

Not when policies get involved.

The Commercialism in Schools policy, No. 913.1, which was adopted by the district in 2003 and updated in 2012, states the obvious, such as rejecting ads that promote violence, disparage ethnic groups, violate the rights of others, and so on. But it also prohibits advertising that “promotes” gambling, alcohol, tobacco, political candidates or parties, products or services which advocate the use of drugs, firearms, adult-themed entertainment, and religion or religious organizations.

You can follow those restrictions right down the rabbit hole. What does “promote” mean? Can ads from Wawa be accepted, since they sell tobacco products? Can ads from a local church be accepted, since they promote religion? Can a beverage distributor advertise, since a large part of their business is selling beer? Can a restaurant advertise, since they serve alcohol? Can Walmart advertise, since they sell guns? If you eliminate any possibility of crossing the line on these restrictions, there's really nobody left who can advertise. 

The board and administration have been chasing these details for months, and they seem no closer to agreement on what to do. As written, the policy states that all advertising “shall be reviewed by the superintendent or his/her designee,” meaning that superintendent John Sanville or his staff will be responsible for vetting every little ad placed in every school publication. That kind of micro-managing is a bit excessive. Anyone who has worked with students and parents knows that ads come in last-minute. Either things are going to be missed, or the superintendent's office is going to have to appoint a full-time ad checker who can respond at the 11th hour as the playbill is going to press.

When three new board members arrive in Unionville-Chadds Ford next month, let's hope that somebody can solve this issue.


Like what you're reading? Subscribe to Chester County's free newsletter to catch every headline



unionville-chadds ford school district advertising advertisement commercialism in schools policy


  • Exploring Science Camp

    08/03/2017
    08:30AM — 12:30PM

    Campers will explore several of the 4-H National Youth Science Day projects which will include wi...


  • 2017 SUMMER KIDS HALF-DAY CAMP IN CHESTER SPRINGS, CHESTER COUNTY: Archaeology Dig for Kids: ...


  • Pawsitive Reading Days

    08/03/2017
    09:30AM — 11:30AM

    Children can read to a non-judgmental listener -- a dog -- at Oxford Feed & Lumber! Ages 3 and up...


  • Ecological Garden Design Workshop

    08/03/2017
    10:00AM — 03:30PM

    Ecologically focused design supports natural processes within and beyond the garden and is especi...


  • Ecological Garden Design

    08/03/2017
    10:00AM — 03:30PM

    Ecologically focused design supports natural processes within and beyond the garden and is especi...


  • Quilt Quest

    08/03/2017
    01:30PM — 03:30PM

    Join us as we journey on a Quilt Quest. Participants will learn basic machine patchwork quilting ...


  • Clutterers Anonymous

    08/03/2017
    06:00PM — 07:00PM

    Clutterers Anonymous℠ (CLA℠) is a fellowship of men and women who share their experience, strengt...


  • Once Upon a Mattress

    08/03/2017
    07:00PM — 09:00PM

    This show will highlight 6-12th grade performers in some really fun roles. If you thought you kne...


  • Cirque Italia

    08/03/2017
    07:30PM — 09:30PM

    GET READY NEWARK, DE, BECAUSE YOU ARE ABOUT TO HAVE THE TIME OF YOUR LIFE! CIRQUE ITALIA, THE F...


  • Trivia Nights at Kennett Square Applebee's

    08/03/2017
    09:00PM — 11:00PM

    Start your studying for trivia nights at the Kennett Square Applebee’s! Trivia nights will be hel...


Chester County High School Sports