Skip to main content

Court says teacher tenure harms students

06/25/2014 09:54AM ● Published by ACL

By Uncle Irvin


In what may become a landmark decision, a California  judge recently ruled that teacher tenure rules deprive students of their constitutional right to a high quality education.

The judge declared that teacher tenure rules are unconstitutional in a decision that will reverberate all across the country. Florida has already put all teachers hired after 2011 on annual contracts. Kansas and North Carolina are seeking to eliminate tenure.

California judge Rolf Treu, who sided with nine student plaintiffs, wrote that, “tenure served no compelling purpose and had led to an unfair, nonsensical system that drove excellent new teachers from classrooms too soon and kept incompetent senior ones. The practice harms students in a way that shocks the conscience and has a disproportionate burden on poor and minority students.”

This judicial decision will hopefully start a ripple effect because it's a wake-up call to policymakers. The problem here in Pennsylvania is that state legislators and senators have no backbone and are scared to death of the teachers union and its opposition to their election.

That's certainly the case for us in southern Chester County. State Representatives John Lawrence and lame-duck Chris Ross and State Senators Dominic Pileggi and Andy Dinniman have no stomach to do what's right because they think it will affect their election.

Those of us who are for the repeal of tenure should let them know that they should fear us.

Like what you're reading? Subscribe to Chester County's free newsletter to catch every headline

uncle irv teachers teacher tenure
  • Bird Walk

    11/25/2017
    09:00AM — 11:00AM

    Newlin Grist Mill and Wild Birds Unlimited-Concordville are teaming up to explore the wonderful w...


  • The Washington Memorial Chapel has announced that the Justice Bell, which serves as the symbol o...


  • Photos with Santa

    11/25/2017
    10:00AM — 09:30PM

    Welcome Santa as he returns to the Concord Mall! Come say "hi" and pose for your holiday photos t...


  • Small Business Saturday

    11/25/2017
    11:00AM — 04:30PM

    Indies First: Small Business Saturday Join us on the Saturday after Thanksgiving and get your ...


  • Brad Rau

    11/25/2017
    07:00PM — 10:00PM

    November 25th Kreutz Creek Winery 7-10 pm Kreutz Creek Winery 44 E Gay St, West Chester, PA 193...


Chester County High School Sports