Skip to main content

GOP cyber/charter bill deserves a D-plus, doesn't save nearly enough

06/06/2013 05:05PM, Published by ACL, Categories: In Print, Opinion

State Rep. James Roebuck, D-Phila., Democratic chairman of the House Education Committee, said the Republican charter and cyber charter school bill reported out of the committee this week deserves a D-plus grade because it doesn't include nearly enough taxpayer savings or financial reforms.

"I have introduced a bill that would save $365 million in the first year and include more financial accountability and more comprehensive reforms to these publicly funded schools. The Republican bill doesn't even come close, and I and other Democrats plan to offer amendments to it in the full House. Without changes, this bill deserves a D-plus because it doesn't save nearly enough," Roebuck said.

Roebuck is pleased the Republican bill, H.B. 618, would remove a "double dip" for cyber charter schools that lets them receive extra funding for pension costs, but he is disappointed the bill would not make the same change to brick-and-mortar charter schools, of which Pennsylvania has nearly 10 times as many. Roebuck also questioned why the cyber-only change would be made for only two years while a commission studies funding - "this needs to be fixed and we should fix it," he said.

Roebuck also is pleased the Republican bill would require a teacher evaluation system for charter and cyber charter school bills similar to the one for other publicly funded schools, and that another bill the committee reported out today (H.B. 980) would apply the same limits on budget surpluses at charter and cyber charter schools already in place for traditional public school districts.


However, Roebuck said H.B. 618 falls short in several areas, including:


* It has weak provisions regarding charter school management organizations' fiscal transparency and conflict of interest issues.

* It still doesn't address special education overpayments.

* It still doesn't include a year-end budget reconciliation between the charter school tuition paid by taxpayers and the schools' actual costs.

* It lacks a ban on using taxpayer funding for advertising by charter and cyber charter schools.

Submitted by the office of State Rep. James Roebuck

Like what you're reading? Subscribe to Chester County's free newsletter to catch every headline

house education committee

You might also like

PSBA testifies on the need for economic furlough option for school districts

Currently, Pennsylvania’s School Code does not allow school districts to furlough professional employees as part of the budget balancing process.

U-CF School Board caps meeting with an icy challenge

John Sanville accepted the ALS Ice Bucket Challenge by donating $100 to ALS research and dumping a cooler of icy water over his head.

  • Hand-blown Glass Open Studio & Sale

    10:00am — 06:00pm

    December 16, 2014 — West Grove, PA. Chester County glassblowers Michael Schunke and Josie Gluck o...

  • Christmas at Milburn Orcha

    11:00am — 03:00pm

    Free photo with Santa! Plus, you are welcome to bring your own camera! Skip the long, hectic li...

  • Christmas Spectacular

    05:00pm — 08:00pm

    Dec. 13 & 20 - Noon – 7pm Gift shop; First 50 shoppers receive a free holiday bag of chips with $...

  • Christmas Spectacular

    05:00pm — 08:00pm

    Dec. 13 & 20 - Noon – 7pm Gift shop; First 50 shoppers receive a free holiday bag of chips with $...

  • Being____ at Christmas

    10:00am — 05:00pm

    Snowy. Jewish. Happy. Caring. Buddhist. Generous. Family. Creative. Friendly. Sparkly. Fill in ...



Chester County High School Sports